Selling ancillary insurance products is about more than simply offering clients another option. Yet, it’s easy to fall into the habit of treating it like one of the most recognizable sales prompts in the world:

“Do you want fries with that?”

It’s a suggestion. A quick add-on. But is it actually a sales conversation, or are you merely an order-taker?

If you offer ancillary products like dental, vision, and hearing, simply letting a client know they exist is a start, but offering a product is not the same as selling it.

Offering ancillary products puts them on the table; selling them means asking the right questions so that clients understand exactly what they need. True consultation goes much deeper than running through a checklist.

Consider how fast-food restaurants have expanded the classic upsell. Instead of offering a side of fries, they bundle items and ask, “Would you like to make that a combo?” Suddenly, they’re showing you how options (like ancillaries) fit together for a better value and to fill your hunger gap.

While it’s true that fast food and insurance are entirely different industries, the core lesson is identical. Making an offer, whether it’s for food or ancillaries, can sound scripted and may feel impersonal. Upselling takes skill to spot a gap, meet a need, and communicate real value.

As an insurance agent, your job isn’t to push another product. It’s to guide the conversation, expose hidden out-of-pocket costs, and help clients make informed decisions. Ask questions that open the door to a meaningful ancillary discussion, and let conversations unfold naturally.

Ask Questions That Start a Conversation

After securing their health plan:

“Now that we’ve reviewed your health coverage, let’s look at whether there are any expenses like out-of-pocket coverage gaps. Would you like to explore ancillary product options that may help cover that?”

When discussing prescription costs:

“You mentioned that prescription costs take a chunk out of your budget. Let’s make sure you understand what your current plan covers and whether there are other options worth exploring.”

When reviewing dental benefits:

“I see your plan provides $500 a year toward dental services. Do you anticipate needing any dental work beyond routine exams and cleanings?”

Don’t settle for being an order-taker who asks, “Do you want fries with that?”

Learn how to lead conversations that help clients understand the entire menu and to decide what makes sense for them.

Follow Messer to master cross-selling. Learn how to guide client conversations that lead to sales. Ask about our training, marketing resources, and digital tools for independent agents. Click HERE to learn more.